Monday, April 7, 2008

Team 5

Which is more desirable -- romance or marriage? Why are the two seen separately?

19 comments:

sjm said...

To me romance seems more desirable than marriage. When Jack Worthing was being interviewed by Lady Bracknell it seemed that all that was important in a marriage was whether or not the man had any money. She didn't care if Gwendolen and Jack loved each other. When I think of romance I think of love, excitement and mystery. Being married to me, in the Victorian era at least, doesn't seem romantic.

diana said...

To me i would have to say romance seems more desirable than marriage. Even if Gwendolen knew Jack wasn't Ernest she still loved him. Even after the shocking news that he was her cousin, she still didn't care because she couldn't stand to be away from him. Back then it was okay to marry your cousin and marriage was something parents discussed between parents and just wanted their son/daughters to marry to a rich man/lady. It didn't matter to them if they loved each other or not but John and Gwendolen showed that even if they are cousin and he lied to her and even if Lady Bracknell was against it they will loved each other. I agree with Siera when i think of romance i think of love, excitement and mystery not marriage and unhappiness. Marriage and romance are totally two different things.

Ka'ili said...

I wanted to do this one Mrs. Idica, so this is my response to the question, along with a little commentary on Siera's and Diana's responses.

In the sense that Siera and Diana put it, romance is obviously more desirable than marriage. The reason why marriage and romance are seen separately I believe is because of the fear of commitment, be it on the man's, woman's, or both of their behalf. people know that romance usually inevitably ends after some major issue between both parties. Granted love for one another may last after the breakup, but the absence of romance makes being intimate with that person feel weird and unattractive. In all honesty, if people can't get past the hard times that romance brings along, it's no wonder that marriage looks intimidating. Marriage actually cannot healthily survive with romance, so marriage can't be separate from romance, but romance can exist without marriage. A healthy romance with no fornication and a healthy relationship prepare a couple for marriage. No fornication of any sort during the pre-marital stage prepares both parties for the commitment part of marriage. It teaches both the man and woman that sex out of wedlock is not acceptable. This usually prevents cheating. After romance, commitment, and love, a marriage has a better chance at being successful. A married couple with these credentials, and even without 100% of them, can feel at ease with growing old with each other. That sounds appealing to me: a commitment to one another in Holy matrimony, with romance, love, affection, and care for one another; as opposed to romance alone without any other quality of marriage and the inevitable breaking-up phase, followed by the post-traumatic depression phase. Marriage, the RIGHT way, is much more appealing to me and, I dare say, to anyone else. Yes marriage has its ups and downs like any other relationship, but with the right morals that were developed before marriage, those problems can be dealt with swiftly.

kanyebear_lova said...

hey sorry this is Team 5's response and this is what we thought in our group discussion. We pretty much had our point of view to what we think is more desirable... Romance or Marriage. We thought about just based on what to our knowledge what should be more desirable which was Romance. Romance is all about being yourself and staying true to what really matters to you and not pretending to be someone else just to impress or make someone except you for who you present in front of them. We also agreed that based on this movie its Marriage. Marriage simply because its all about the social ranking values in this society. You must marry within your own class. Its immoral to marry someone who is of lower class. The more highly and sociable class wouldnt dare to go outside their class. But the ones who do wanna seek more than just someone with wealth and power.
When lady bracknell was interviewing Jack, she was looking for wealth and not that he loved her or not. When you think about both romance and marriage affects everything in society, but the two are different.

shinzoyuri said...

Well in reality romance is the best option, but in different situations marriage is the apporaite choice. The main reason that they are seen separately is that marriage is pretty much for a life time, while romance varies. In the Victorian era, marriage was based off of a persons' status and the amount of wealth they had. Preferably I like romance just because you can change for the better rather than be stuck with someone you don't want to be with.

tiniBOP! said...

i feel that in the Victorian age society accepts marriage based on many other things , but those who are of the younger generation living in the Victorian age desire romance. For myself depending on the situation i would choose both. I think romance is there to fit you needs and I'm sure everyone wants romance. IT was hard because marriage was based on where you came from and if the families will make the perfect match. All the responses did make a good point though. I just feel that its weird how in the Victorian age it had to be an option to chose between the two.

Anonymous said...

I also agree with diana and siearam that romance is most desireable. Gwendalyn wanted romance more than anything, she knew in her heart that jack was for her, but her mother on the other hand didnt approve because jack wasnt up to her standards. Lady braknell focused on only marriage and leaving romance out of the question. In the victorian era, all that they considered was social ranking when they thought of marriage.

imua said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
imua said...

Romance is more desirable.
Like everyone said, back then, especially upper class, it was tradition to marry someone of wealth or royalty. Usually the parents would arrange the marriage. The movie showed that clearly; how Lady Bracknell would not allow Jack to marry Gwen just because of his status. Lady B did not care for her daughter's feelings or thoughts.

Anonymous said...

MARRIAGE!
If I were an eligible female in the Victorian era I would still dream of a knight in shinning armor to sweep me off my feet. However, I would find it more important to be married into a rich family than to engage in a school girl romance. From the time I was a child I understood the value of money. Not having anything teaches you to always have a strategy and a plan. A woman in the Victorian era MUST be married in order to have any shot at a decent life. Marriage isn’t about holding hands and drawing hearts in your notebook. Marriage is about trust, endurance, respect, and responsibility. Maybe I’m just a pessimist; or maybe I’m a realist. Because, in reality YOU CAN’T LIVE ON LOVE AND ROMANCE!

Anonymous said...

i think romance is more desirable than marriage. Like the movie The Wedding Planner. Mary[Jennifer Lopez] falls in love with a pediatrician who saves her from a dumpster that was rolling at her. However, the man who saves her, Steve[Matthew McConaughey] is a groom of one of the weddings she's planning, and her father arranged for her to get married. In the end, neither get married because they aren't in love with the person they were about to marry.
I thought this movie was a perfect example of how romance is more desirable than marriage.

leahvaldez said...

your only ticket into marriage in the Victorian ages was your income and family name. It was more a background check if anything. it seemed that if you were in romance in that era and your partner had no money to his/her name you, were living in a dreamland! romance would be my pick because,its your feelings. Many marriages have been set up and people just marry each other because they HAVE to. But when you have romance YOU have the ultimate power to love who you want. DEM VICTORIAN PEEPS..DEY CRAZY!!

Anonymous said...

I believe that romance is much more important. The word makes me picture two people who genuinely love each other. Marriage has lost some its importance nowadays and there doesn't seem to be enough value for it. In the Victorian era, marriage became more of a business decision rather than because you were in love. It was one of the few things a girl could look forward to in life. It all depended on whether or not there was enough money involved, or the suitor came from a good blood line. I would rather be in love than marry for money.

Anonymous said...

In my opinion, romance is more desirable than marriage. Back in the Victorian Era, it seemed like marriage was dealt with between the parents. Even though Jack and Gwendelen loved each other, Lady Bracknell didn't approve of their marriage. All Lady Bracknell cared about was the status of Jack and his assets. Lady Bracknell disapproved Jack because he didn't have parents at that time. Basically the Victorian Era was about forced marriage. Romance is about the affection you share with your significant other. Money, status, etc shouldn't matter. Just the love you have for each other.

poopookaka in my wii wii said...

gosh everyone is picking romance over

well i guess i will be the one to say that marriage is better than romance. although romance is very exciting and everyone wants it.

but in the long run mariage is something most people seek.


you can always play the field and be a PLAYER and have fun with your life but theres goign to be a time where your not goign to be attracice anymore. in the end how do you have to go home too. Or to keep you company when your sick, and tell you that they love you everyday, someone to telll your feelings.

thats what mariage is someone that will always be there for you9unles there is a divorce). and not some flavor of the week or month or cuz she is hot.

and i personally dont want to be a 50 year old guy and pimp'n around and not married. unlesss im that playboy guy haha.

wasmean said...

I don't think I'd be able to call something a marriage without it having romance.

But referring to the movie...like siera, when Lady Bracknell interviewed Jack. She interviewed him because the of the proposal of marriage towards her daughter. Not because he "loved" her. He even told Lady Bracknell that, but God forbid her daughter marry a man who was found in a bag at a train station. Obviously marriage is by far seen as something much more important than romance.

=รพ

Michaela said...

If the question is directed towards me personally then I would say ROMANCE. Romance is much more powerful and FUN! There is so much work that goes into a marriage(so i have been told) There are many people who get married for reasons that do not pertain to love. But shouldn't you get married to someone you love? shouldn't love and romance be the key!
In the Victorian Era it seems like marriage was much more of importance then love.

Anonymous said...

In my opinion Marriage would be more desirable because when your married you are with someone who you really know, trust, and love, mentally, physically, emotionaly,and romanticaly. Being in a marraiage can be difficult and sometimes you lose love between one another but the experience of being in a marriage is being creative to help keep your love alive. Also in a marriage you can be romantically invovled with each other any time you want and in our society today it would be okay because you MARRIED! But i also agree with SIERA that being Married in the Victorian era doesnt seem romantic.

onenonly said...

I feel that a marriage is more desirable than a romance because marriage shows commitment and loyalty. I think marriage is the final event that commits a couple to one another. I think romance is just a small relationship that doesn’t have as much commitment to one another. Plus back in those days marriage was the ultimate goal of most women.