Welcome to our Aiea High School class blog! Here you will be able to share your reflections on the class assignments and read your classmates thoughts.
Monday, April 7, 2008
Team 4
How did the Victorian values make it attractive to have a "dual identity"?
When team 4 had discussed this question we came up with many different answers that were all similar.
The most common of all answers were that with a "dual identity" you can be who you want to be. Because you have a different identity you choose the path of your "new" life. Leah had made a point about choosing your own life because they might not like the one they pursue now. Not only that, with their new life they can please whoever they want which makes it all the more attractive. Austin added to that by saying they could pretty much juice up their life is they wanted to and no one would know unless the truth is revealed. ( If Austin had a dual identity he wants 3 dogs.) haha Michaela brought up a really great talking point about having a "dual identity" in the Victorian age could be attractive because these people are able to fulfill their fantasies. And it linked back to how they can make themselves look as great as they want. I had also pointed out that and Shaena supported me with this about how "dual identities" supported euphemisms in the Victorian Age. Because these people were so high class and prudish they were able to cover up their lives and put sugar coating on what wasnt seen. So to those people who didnt know these bunburys were attractive but litle did they know, they dont have attractive lives at all.
We also came to the realization that during the Victorian age, people must have been very gullible to believe people with "dual identities". Although we have only witnesses this in the movie it made us wonder if this truly reflect how people were. It also made us laugh a little at how they could be so gullible because im pretty sure we assumed that they might be stupid on top of that to believe them. I then brought up that maybe in the Victorian age this act is attractive because people like the mystery of it. We all talked about how Jack went to town and the country people always wondered where and why he went and vice versa.
After talking about these topics, Austin brought up that this "dual identity" if it fits in the right time period kind of reflects the Titanic movie. After making some similarities Leah had pointed out that the Titanic is the perfect example of a "dual identity" going all wrong.
In all we came pretty much agreed that the attractiveness of this act is that you can be who you want to be.
man we are too goood! pshh. and Te Jay said Leah and Michaela weren't scholars. psh.
This was my other questions that i circled to do, basically I agree with what team 4 had to say about victorian values make it attractive to have a "dual identity." They said everything that i would have said. Having a "duel identity" makes it easier for you to live a life you always dreamed of living because no one knows the true you. You can do anything you wish to do to please yourself because the truth is a secret. Although secrets don't stay a secret forever. "Duel identity" is like sugar coating some words like the victorian vaules. For example you could say that I like to have a big manson with 2 cars and 3 maids and 4 dogs with a pool. But in reality thats not the life i want to live because its too fancy, everything is easily done and I'm not that happy. I can have a duel identity and be someone who lives in an apartment with no maid, no dogs, no cars and has everything else in the world that makes you happy like friends :). Its kind of like being a hypocrite but not really. Your life just ended up the way it happened but your not satisified enough that you ended up having another life in another shoe living the life you always wanted.
I also agree with team 4 and Diana. Victorian values were very strict. It must have been a drag to try to live up to Victorian morals seeing as that during that time people were highly judgemental. Having a dual identity would have been exciting. You could be someone you were not or someone you wish you could be without having your actual identity tarnished.
i agree with everyones comments on this question. with this dual identity, you are able to be a completely different person, giving you the chance of playing with peoples mind. like in the movie where the identities came out and the girls were appalled by the truth. you could be having this dual identity because in real life you can't act the way you want to be. being in a certain social class, of course you had to act a certain way because thats just the way most act in you're class. so it's fun having an identity where you can "free" you're secretive feelings.
I agree with ness who agrees with everyone who commented on this question. It seemed that the Victorian period were segregated by social class and that people would want "dual identity" to live their life the way they want. "So it's fun having an identity where you can 'free' you're secretive feelings" -ness. That's all I have to say about that.
Having a "dual identity" is so that you can be anyone you want to be. So basically, I agree with Team 4 and everyone else. When you make a new identity for yourself in a different place, you can do whatever you want since no one knows you. Its fun being another person because you can have a new name, a car, and a fabulous job, or whatever you want.
I think Victorian values made it attractive to have a "dual identity" because there was such a high standard to live up to. I agree with a lot of what Team 4 said about how you're able to become whoever you want to be. People in this era must of been so bored with having to always be proper and respectable. I agree with how Michaela said it allows you to live out your fantasies. Nobody's perfect all the time. You need a break every now and then to just let loose.
The Victorian values made "Dual identites" so attractive because in society back then, people were to live and act a certain way and basically be a whole diffrent person from who they truley are. (As did uncle jack). So I agree with what everyone had to say. With having a dual Idenity, you were now free from societys morals, and values and were now capable of making up a whole new peorson. And just as Michaela said you were now able to fulfill your fantasies, and just live out as you would want it to be.
"All the world's a stage, and all the men and woman merely players" (Shakespeare's As You Like It).
The purpose of having a dual identity, as stated before, is to live freely as another entity or persona. I do agree with the statements prior to mine saying that owning a dual identity allows the ties of the social hierarchy to be cut. I believe it allowed the characters in the film to live out their own personal desires without restraint. Such can still be said about today's society where we all are free to choose how to act at certain functions or scenarios, just as "Jack" and "Earnest" did.
I totally agreee with everyone elses comments. Having a dual identity is amazing because you can be who you really want to be. Duriing the victorian era, they couldnt really be the person they wanted to be, so they made up a totally different person. I believe people have dual identites to get away from reality and live in their fantasies.
well i totally agree like you can like 2 lives like a super hero
because you word is what people will believe. what ever you say by day you can be "dave johnson" the ice cream delivery man and at night you can be "kimo kamuellahaafaatuafefanotiliiliisongasu" and if thats the life you want to live then so be it. what you do on your own time is nobodys bussiness.
and in victorian day everyone must be just a certian way to be of a certian class and do certain things of a certain way that wont make you look less of your certain status
people couldnt handle that so they found a way to release that pressure with out hurting who they were and their nobleliy.
To me I feel that back in the Victorian period you were born into a life style. Therefore, by having two identities you can choose who you want to be instead of being forced into a life you might not like. I agree with the group’s response about being able to make your life as good as you want it to be. Also by having a dual identity you can do whatever you want without having your true self revealed and demoralized. Like everyone else said if you weren’t able to live up to the high Victorian standards you can be someone else.
13 comments:
When team 4 had discussed this question we came up with many different answers that were all similar.
The most common of all answers were that with a "dual identity" you can be who you want to be. Because you have a different identity you choose the path of your "new" life.
Leah had made a point about choosing your own life because they might not like the one they pursue now. Not only that, with their new life they can please whoever they want which makes it all the more attractive.
Austin added to that by saying they could pretty much juice up their life is they wanted to and no one would know unless the truth is revealed.
( If Austin had a dual identity he wants 3 dogs.) haha
Michaela brought up a really great talking point about having a "dual identity" in the Victorian age could be attractive because these people are able to fulfill their fantasies. And it linked back to how they can make themselves look as great as they want.
I had also pointed out that and Shaena supported me with this about how "dual identities" supported euphemisms in the Victorian Age. Because these people were so high class and prudish they were able to cover up their lives and put sugar coating on what wasnt seen. So to those people who didnt know these bunburys were attractive but litle did they know, they dont have attractive lives at all.
We also came to the realization that during the Victorian age, people must have been very gullible to believe people with "dual identities". Although we have only witnesses this in the movie it made us wonder if this truly reflect how people were.
It also made us laugh a little at how they could be so gullible because im pretty sure we assumed that they might be stupid on top of that to believe them.
I then brought up that maybe in the Victorian age this act is attractive because people like the mystery of it. We all talked about how Jack went to town and the country people always wondered where and why he went and vice versa.
After talking about these topics, Austin brought up that this "dual identity" if it fits in the right time period kind of reflects the Titanic movie. After making some similarities Leah had pointed out that the Titanic is the perfect example of a "dual identity" going all wrong.
In all we came pretty much agreed that the attractiveness of this act is that you can be who you want to be.
man we are too goood!
pshh. and Te Jay said Leah and Michaela weren't scholars. psh.
This was my other questions that i circled to do, basically I agree with what team 4 had to say about victorian values make it attractive to have a "dual identity." They said everything that i would have said. Having a "duel identity" makes it easier for you to live a life you always dreamed of living because no one knows the true you. You can do anything you wish to do to please yourself because the truth is a secret. Although secrets don't stay a secret forever. "Duel identity" is like sugar coating some words like the victorian vaules. For example you could say that I like to have a big manson with 2 cars and 3 maids and 4 dogs with a pool. But in reality thats not the life i want to live because its too fancy, everything is easily done and I'm not that happy. I can have a duel identity and be someone who lives in an apartment with no maid, no dogs, no cars and has everything else in the world that makes you happy like friends :). Its kind of like being a hypocrite but not really. Your life just ended up the way it happened but your not satisified enough that you ended up having another life in another shoe living the life you always wanted.
I also agree with team 4 and Diana. Victorian values were very strict. It must have been a drag to try to live up to Victorian morals seeing as that during that time people were highly judgemental. Having a dual identity would have been exciting. You could be someone you were not or someone you wish you could be without having your actual identity tarnished.
i agree with everyones comments on this question. with this dual identity, you are able to be a completely different person, giving you the chance of playing with peoples mind. like in the movie where the identities came out and the girls were appalled by the truth. you could be having this dual identity because in real life you can't act the way you want to be. being in a certain social class, of course you had to act a certain way because thats just the way most act in you're class. so it's fun having an identity where you can "free" you're secretive feelings.
I agree with ness who agrees with everyone who commented on this question. It seemed that the Victorian period were segregated by social class and that people would want "dual identity" to live their life the way they want. "So it's fun having an identity where you can 'free' you're secretive feelings" -ness. That's all I have to say about that.
Having a "dual identity" is so that you can be anyone you want to be. So basically, I agree with Team 4 and everyone else. When you make a new identity for yourself in a different place, you can do whatever you want since no one knows you. Its fun being another person because you can have a new name, a car, and a fabulous job, or whatever you want.
I think Victorian values made it attractive to have a "dual identity" because there was such a high standard to live up to. I agree with a lot of what Team 4 said about how you're able to become whoever you want to be. People in this era must of been so bored with having to always be proper and respectable. I agree with how Michaela said it allows you to live out your fantasies. Nobody's perfect all the time. You need a break every now and then to just let loose.
The Victorian values made "Dual identites" so attractive because in society back then, people were to live and act a certain way and basically be a whole diffrent person from who they truley are. (As did uncle jack). So I agree with what everyone had to say. With having a dual Idenity, you were now free from societys morals, and values and were now capable of making up a whole new peorson. And just as Michaela said you were now able to fulfill your fantasies, and just live out as you would want it to be.
"All the world's a stage, and all the men and woman merely players" (Shakespeare's As You Like It).
The purpose of having a dual identity, as stated before, is to live freely as another entity or persona. I do agree with the statements prior to mine saying that owning a dual identity allows the ties of the social hierarchy to be cut. I believe it allowed the characters in the film to live out their own personal desires without restraint. Such can still be said about today's society where we all are free to choose how to act at certain functions or scenarios, just as "Jack" and "Earnest" did.
I totally agreee with everyone elses comments. Having a dual identity is amazing because you can be who you really want to be. Duriing the victorian era, they couldnt really be the person they wanted to be, so they made up a totally different person. I believe people have dual identites to get away from reality and live in their fantasies.
wow thanks tini
you put a quote on quote there haha.
well i totally agree
like you can like 2 lives like a super hero
because you word is what people will believe. what ever you say by day you can be "dave johnson" the ice cream delivery man and at night you can be "kimo kamuellahaafaatuafefanotiliiliisongasu" and if thats the life you want to live then so be it. what you do on your own time is nobodys bussiness.
and in victorian day everyone must be just a certian way to be of a certian class and do certain things of a certain way that wont make you look less of your certain status
people couldnt handle that so they found a way to release that pressure with out hurting who they were and their nobleliy.
To me I feel that back in the Victorian period you were born into a life style. Therefore, by having two identities you can choose who you want to be instead of being forced into a life you might not like. I agree with the group’s response about being able to make your life as good as you want it to be. Also by having a dual identity you can do whatever you want without having your true self revealed and demoralized. Like everyone else said if you weren’t able to live up to the high Victorian standards you can be someone else.
Post a Comment